Rating:
1 vote

South Fork Pottawatomie Creek Bridge

Photos 

Photo taken by Robert Elder in March 2005

Enlarge

BH Photo #111279

Map 

Facts 

Overview
Concrete pony arch bridge over South Fork Pottawatomie Creek, 0.5 mi. south and 3.7 mi. east of Garnett
Location
Anderson County, Kansas
Status
Replaced by a new bridge
History
Built 1934
Design
Rainbow arch
Dimensions
Span length: 89.9 ft.
Total length: 89.9 ft.
Deck width: 20.0 ft.
Approximate latitude, longitude
+38.28075, -95.18019   (decimal degrees)
38°16'51" N, 95°10'49" W   (degrees°minutes'seconds")
Approximate UTM coordinates
15/309306/4239213 (zone/easting/northing)
Quadrangle map:
Garnett East
Inventory numbers
KS 000000000020023 (Kansas local bridge number on the National Bridge Inventory)
BH 17346 (Bridgehunter.com ID)
Inspection (as of 11/2009)
Deck condition rating: Satisfactory (6 out of 9)
Superstructure condition rating: Fair (5 out of 9)
Substructure condition rating: Fair (5 out of 9)
Appraisal: Functionally obsolete
Sufficiency rating: 48.1 (out of 100)
Average daily traffic (as of 2007)
517

Update Log 

  • October 19, 2016: Updated by Robert Elder: Added category "Marsh arch (standard)"
  • June 23, 2012: Updated by Ruth Reynolds: Updated status.
  • March 16, 2010: Updated by Robert Elder: Adjusted GPS Coordinates
  • December 8, 2009: Updated by Robert Elder: Added Marsh arch to Categories.
  • July 8, 2008: Updated by Robert Elder: Updated categories
  • February 28, 2008: Updated by Robert Elder: Edited "Overview" "Design" and "Design Description"
  • February 5, 2008: New photos from Robert Elder

Sources 

  • Robert Elder - robertelder1 [at] gmail [dot] com
  • Ruth Reynolds - ruthmusic [at] yahoo [dot] com

Comments 

South Fork Pottawatomie Creek Bridge
Posted January 12, 2012, by Robert Elder (robertelder1 [at] gmail [dot] com)

Nathan:

I am not certain if federal funds are being used for this project or not. I have tried to find an article about the replacement, but I have had no luck so far. Based on NBI data, the deck width is the main issue with this bridge. This is no surprise as the deck geometry, not the structural integrity is why many Marsh arches get replaced.

Naturally, Sec. 106 does not apply to this bridge as it is not on the NRHP. According to the latest NBI information, it is possibly eligible. It is my understanding that KDOT and KSHS are working on surveying potentially historic bridges again, but as of now, they are working from historical surveys conducted in the 1980s. At that time, there were roughly 76 Marsh arch bridges remaining in Kansas, but that number has been reduced to roughly 29. At least two of those bridges, and possibly a third will be demolished in 2012.

South Fork Pottawatomie Creek Bridge
Posted January 11, 2012, by Nathan Holth (form3 [at] historicbridges [dot] org)

It is my observation that this replacement is not only destroying an extremely rare bridge type it also is completely unneeded and a massive waste of tax payer dollars based on traffic volumes, deck width, and structure condition. I also find projects like this suspicious when the sufficiency rating is only 2 or less points away from the threshold of getting federal replacement funding. How convenient that all those inspection reports, equations, and variables all just happened to calculate just enough so that it could be replaced. Although there are rigorous standard and processes for bridge inspections, there is a small amount of subjective flexibility, enough that I suspect it would be possible to "tweak" results to something favorable by someone seeking replacement funding.

Or am I jumping to conclusions? Is federal funding even involved here? Or does Kansas do like Michigan and use state funds only for bridge projects, conveniently bypassing Section 106? I assume this bridge is eligible for the National Register. If it wasn't considered eligible, the finding is either outdated or conducted by someone inexperienced in historic bridges.

South Fork Pottawatomie Creek Bridge
Posted January 10, 2012, by Robert Elder (robertelder1 [at] gmail [dot] com)

Another Marsh arch bites the dust...

South Fork Pottawatomie Creek Bridge
Posted January 10, 2012, by Ruth Reynolds (ruthmusic [at] yahoo [dot] com)

This bridge is currently closed and is being replaced.